... the experts forum for discussion and information
Published quarterly and distributed free to all
registered expert witnesses, Your Witness acts as a forum
for the discussion and dissemination of information relevant to
practising expert witnesses.
Coverage ranges from highly topical issues (such as legal reform
and court reports) to more background business matters
(including getting paid, fees, disbursements
and much more).
The following table shows the contents of the last four issues.
To gauge the quality of Your Witness firsthand, you can
||Expert witnesses are busy people and have to juggle their available time as best they can. The courts, too, with increasingly overstretched resources, must endeavour to manage court time as efficiently as possible. But, what would you do if you found yourself warned for a whole 3 months! We consider the issue of trial windows, trial dates and how the witness summons can become a very blunt tool. Also inside this issue we report on an interesting side issue that arose in the Dr Squier case about whether disciplinary tribunals can refer to earlier trials in which the expert was criticised by the judge. Being instructed in a case when you have a connection with one of the parties needs to be handled with great care and openness. We discuss a recent case in which the expert fell down badly in this respect and stress the importance of early action to highlight any connection. It is a common enough experience for experts in the witness box to find the barrister ‘playing the man’ when they realise they have no way to undermine the evidence itself. It is, therefore, refreshing to hear that one judge, at least, has had more than enough of it.
||Publicly confronting dogma is a risky business that can have long-lasting consequences. The situation of Dr Squier is a case in point, an expert who challenged professional dogma on ‘shaken baby syndrome’ and has spent the past year or two defending herself in professional disciplinary proceedings. Apart from the revealing light her case casts on the GMC’s (in)ability to conduct its business effectively, it holds important lessons for any expert who believes professional conventional wisdom needs to be confronted. Also inside this issue we look at how you can deal with appeals from your instructing lawyer to change your report. While some such requests are perfectly valid, others are most certainly not. A growing market for medical experts is requests from employers for a medical report on an employee (or potential employee), we look at what issues this raises for the expert. A recent decision of Birmingham County Court has suggested that in some circumstances the court can order the disclosure of items such as draft documents, and even a solicitor’s attendance note of conversations with experts! If this principle is correct, it will ring alarm bells for experts and lawyers alike. Finally we responsed to a couple of helpline questions on instructions that suddenly involve a litigant in person, and on dealing with requests to defer billing for extended periods.
||In this issue we look at what awaits the expert witness in Brexit Britain. It’s early days, but the likelihood is that after the huge task of extraction is completed not much will have changed! We examine a case in which the medical expert got his role comprehensively wrong, and subsequently suffered at the hands of the GMC. Despite the furore caused by the publication in 2012 of a report by psychologist Jane Ireland, Evaluating Expert Witness Psychological Reports: Exploring Quality, the matter has come full circle. We recap events from 2012 before looking at recent developments at the Health and Care Professions Council as it exonerates Professor Ireland at a hearing in the summer. From time to time we become aware of articles written by expert members of the UK Register of Expert Witnesses. In this issue, we carry such a piece penned by retail fraud expert Richard Emery, in which he considers some of the problems in the way public funding is being used in the criminal courts. We round up with a quick look at some topical news.
||In this issue we look at a new complication for experts who undertake work for litigants in person – consumer law! Are you ready for on- and off-premises contracts and cancellation rights? We set out everything you need to know. We also investigate an interesting issue that arose when the police came knocking on an expert's door asking for a copy of a civil court report he had written because the CPS wanted to use it in criminal proceedings. And you may have heard about vulnerable witnesses who give evidence from behind a screen, but can an expert witness remain anonymous in proceedings? We find out. We also take a quick look at a case in which the expert got his role comprehensively wrong, and round up with a bit of topical news.
What the experts say
I receive various publications from
the Academy of Experts, Expert Witness Institute and Chartered Institute
of Arbitrators, all of which I try to read, more or less, or at
least scan through for useful information. Your Witness is easy
to read... and contains information useful to me and other experts.
In my opinion, the best source of information of them all!
Terry Wolfe, Flooring Consultant
... as always, [Your Witness]...
is an informative and stimulating publication in keeping with the
generally very high standard of the UK Register of Expert Witnesses.
Dr P K Buxton, Consultant Dermatologist
Can I compliment you on the periodic
publication of Your Witness, which I find informative and very readable.
Mike Lucas, Management Consultant and Knot Analyst